How to Create Internal SSL Certificate for pfSense Firewall?

Security is no longer optional in network administration; it is fundamental. For pfSense firewall users, one of the simplest yet most powerful security measures is enabling HTTPS through SSL certificates.

An SSL certificate ensures that every communication between your browser and the pfSense WebGUI is encrypted and trusted. Without it, sensitive configuration data can be exposed to attackers, and administrators are left with warning-filled logins that undermine trust.

While many networks use certificates from trusted public authorities, pfSense also gives you the ability to create an internal SSL certificate. This option is especially useful for organizations running closed networks, schools managing internal systems, or businesses that don’t want the overhead of recurring public SSL renewals. 

By generating your own certificate authority (CA) and issuing internal SSL certificates, you can establish a trusted and encrypted environment for pfSense without depending entirely on third-party providers.

This article will walk you through, step by step, how to create internal SSL certificate for pfSense firewall. You’ll also learn to configure the certificates and how this applies to Windows and Android clients. I’ll take you through how pfSense integrates with tools like Let’s Encrypt, and why managing your pfSense SSL certificates correctly is critical to both security and usability.

If you’re ready to take the next step in your tech career journey, cybersecurity is the simplest and high-paying field to start from. Apart from earning 6-figures from the comfort of your home, you don’t need to have a degree or IT background. Schedule a one-on-one consultation session with our expert cybersecurity coach, Tolulope Michael TODAY! Join over 1000 students in sharing your success stories.

RELATED ARTICLE: pfSense Dual Home BGP Networks Setup

What Are SSL Certificates in pfSense?

To secure pfSense effectively, you first need to understand what role SSL certificates play. An SSL certificate is a digital passport that verifies the identity of your firewall and encrypts all traffic between your browser and the pfSense WebGUI. When configured correctly, it ensures that no outsider can intercept or tamper with sensitive data such as admin credentials or firewall settings.

There are three main approaches to SSL in pfSense:

• Self-signed certificates – These are generated automatically during pfSense installation. While they do provide encryption, they are not trusted by browsers. That’s why you usually see a “Not Secure” or “Untrusted” warning when logging into pfSense the first time.
  
• Public CA certificates (e.g., LetsEncrypt, DigiCert, Sectigo) – These certificates are signed by trusted certificate authorities. Browsers recognize them as legitimate because they are part of the global trust chain. pfSense can integrate directly with LetsEncrypt via the ACME package, making it easier to manage renewals for public-facing services.
  
• Internal SSL certificates – These are issued by a certificate authority (CA) that you create and manage within pfSense. While not publicly trusted, internal certificates are ideal for private environments where you control both the server (pfSense) and the client machines. By distributing your internal CA to those clients, you eliminate browser warnings and maintain strong encryption without relying on an external provider.

The type of certificate you choose depends on your needs. If your pfSense firewall is only accessed internally, an internal SSL certificate backed by your own pfSense certificate authority makes perfect sense. If your firewall needs to be accessible from the internet, a pfSense SSL certificate with Let’s Encrypt provides browser-trusted security.

By understanding these differences, you’ll be better equipped to decide whether to create your own pfSense certificate authority or use a public provider, and how to manage the pfSense HTTPS certificate in a way that balances convenience, trust, and security.

Step 1 – Create a Certificate Authority (CA) in pfSense

The foundation of creating an internal SSL certificate in pfSense is setting up your own Certificate Authority (CA). Think of the CA as the trusted root that will sign and validate all certificates you generate for pfSense. Without it, browsers won’t know whether to trust the SSL certificate assigned to your firewall.

Here’s how to create a CA in pfSense:

1. Log in to pfSense WebGUI
   
   • Use your browser to access the pfSense firewall. By default, it may still show a browser warning since the self-signed certificate is active.
     
2. Navigate to the Cert Manager
   
   • Go to: System > Cert Manager > CAs tab.
     
   • Click the + Add button to create a new Certificate Authority.
     
3. Select “Create an internal Certificate Authority”
   
   • Under the Method dropdown, choose Create an internal Certificate Authority.
     
4. Fill in CA Details
   
   • Descriptive Name: Something recognizable, like Internal-CA or pfSense-CA.
     
   • Country Code, State, City, Organization: Enter the relevant organizational details.
     
   • Common Name (CN): A unique identifier for your CA. Avoid using the same CN as your firewall hostname.
     
   • Key Type and Length: Choose RSA 2048-bit or RSA 4096-bit for stronger security.
     
   • Digest Algorithm: SHA256 is the recommended option for compatibility and security.
     
   • Lifetime (days): Defines how long your CA will remain valid. Many administrators use a long validity period (e.g., 3650 days = 10 years) to avoid frequent renewals.
     
5. Save and Secure the CA
   
   • Click Save to create the CA.
     
   • pfSense will now store the CA and its private key securely in its configuration database.

]Always back up your CA configuration securely. If the private key is lost or compromised, every certificate signed by that CA becomes invalid or unsafe.

Step 2 – Create an Internal Server Certificate

Now that you have a Certificate Authority (CA) in place, the next step is to create the internal SSL server certificate that will be used by pfSense. This certificate will prove the identity of your firewall to client devices and enable encrypted HTTPS access.

Here’s how to set it up:

1. Access the Certificates Tab
   
   • Go to System > Cert Manager > Certificates tab.
     
   • Click the + Add button to create a new certificate.
     
2. Choose “Create an internal Certificate”
   
   • In the Method dropdown, select Create an internal Certificate.
     
   • This option lets you issue a server certificate directly from the CA you created in the previous step.
     
3. Fill in Certificate Details
   
   • Descriptive Name: Something like pfSense-WebGUI-Cert.
     
   • Certificate Authority: Select the internal CA you created earlier.
     
   • Common Name (CN): This must match the Fully Qualified Domain Name (FQDN) or IP address you’ll use to access pfSense (e.g., pfsense.local or 192.168.1.1).
     
   • Alternative Names (SANs): Add both the FQDN and the firewall’s IP address here. This ensures browsers trust the certificate whether you connect by domain or IP.
     
   • Key Type/Length: Use the same settings as your CA (RSA 2048 or RSA 4096 with SHA256).
     
   • Certificate Type: Select Server Certificate.
     
4. Save the Certificate
   
   • Once you save, pfSense will generate the internal SSL certificate signed by your CA.
     
   • You should now see it listed in the Certificates tab.

If you only set the Common Name to pfsense.local but access the firewall by IP address, browsers will still show warnings. Adding both in the SAN field avoids this problem.

At this stage, you’ve successfully created a valid SSL certificate signed by your own pfSense certificate authority. The next step is to actually assign it to the WebGUI so that your admin interface runs over HTTPS securely.

READ MORE: MSP vs ITaaS: A Complete 2025 Analysis

Step 3 – Assign SSL Certificate to pfSense WebGUI

Creating the certificate is only half the process. To make it effective, you must assign the SSL certificate to the pfSense WebGUI so that all administrative access happens securely over HTTPS.

Here’s how to do it:

1. Navigate to Admin Access Settings
   
   • Go to System > Advanced > Admin Access tab.
     
2. Enable HTTPS Protocol
   
   • Under Protocol, select HTTPS.
     
   • This ensures the WebConfigurator no longer uses unencrypted HTTP.
     
3. Select the New SSL Certificate
   
   • In the SSL/TLS Certificate dropdown, choose the internal server certificate you created in the previous step (pfSense-WebGUI-Cert).
     
   • This replaces the default self-signed certificate with your trusted internal one.
     
4. (Optional) Change the WebGUI Port
   
   • By default, pfSense uses port 443 for HTTPS. For added security, you may configure a non-standard port (e.g., 8443).
     
   • This reduces exposure to automated attacks that commonly target default ports.
     
5. Save and Apply Settings
   
   • Click Save at the bottom of the page.
     
   • pfSense will reload the WebGUI using the new certificate. You may need to log in again.
     
6. Verify the Assignment
   
   • Open your browser and connect to pfSense using HTTPS.
     
   • Inspect the certificate details: the issuer should be your internal CA, and the Common Name/SAN should match the hostname or IP you used.

Tip: If you haven’t yet installed the internal CA on your client device, you’ll still see browser warnings at this stage. The certificate is valid, but your system doesn’t recognize the CA until you import it.

Step 4 – Distribute Root CA to Clients

At this point, pfSense is configured with your internal SSL certificate. However, browsers and devices will still show security warnings until they recognize the internal Certificate Authority (CA) you created. To resolve this, you must distribute the root CA certificate to all client devices that access the pfSense WebGUI.

Here’s how to do it:

1. Export the Root CA from pfSense

• Go to System > Cert Manager > CAs tab.
  
• Locate the CA you created earlier.
  
• Under Actions, click Export.
  
• Save the certificate file (usually in .crt or .pem format) to your computer.

2. Install the Root CA on Windows Clients

• Open the Run dialog (Win + R), type mmc, and press Enter.
  
• In the console, go to File > Add/Remove Snap-in.
  
• Add Certificates (Local Computer), then click OK.
  
• Expand Trusted Root Certification Authorities > Certificates.
  
• Right-click, choose Import, and select the CA file you exported.
  
• Complete the wizard, and your Windows machine will now trust the pfSense SSL certificate.

3. Install the Root CA on Android Clients

• Transfer the CA file to your Android device.
  
• Go to Settings > Security > Encryption & credentials (this may vary by manufacturer).
  
• Tap Install a certificate > CA certificate.
  
• Select the exported CA file and confirm the installation.
  
• Once installed, your Android device will trust the pfSense SSL certificate.

4. Why This Step Matters

Without importing the CA, your browser will always flag the certificate as untrusted, even if it’s valid. Once the CA is installed, client devices will recognize your pfSense WebGUI certificate as legitimate, and you’ll enjoy smooth, warning-free HTTPS access.

SEE ALSO: pfSense vs VyOS: A Complete Analysis

Testing and Validation

Once you’ve assigned the SSL certificate and distributed the CA to your client devices, it’s time to test and validate your configuration. Validation ensures that your pfSense WebGUI is not only encrypted but also trusted across all the devices you use to manage the firewall.

1. Browser Validation

• Open your browser and connect to pfSense using https:// followed by the hostname or IP you configured.
  
• Click the padlock icon in the browser’s address bar.
  
• Inspect the certificate details to confirm:
  
  • The certificate is issued by your internal CA.
    
  • The Common Name (CN) and Subject Alternative Names (SANs) match the address you used.
    
  • The certificate is valid (not expired).

If all these are correct, the browser should display a secure connection without warnings.

2. Cross-Device Testing

• Test from both Windows and Android devices where you installed the CA.
  
• Confirm that neither device prompts security warnings when accessing the pfSense WebGUI.

3. Command-Line Validation with OpenSSL

For deeper verification, you can use OpenSSL from a terminal:

openssl s_client -connect pfsense.local:443 -showcerts

This command displays the full certificate chain. Check that:

• The chain includes your internal CA.
  
• No errors such as “unable to verify the first certificate” appear.
  

4. Online SSL Testing Tools

Although internal certificates aren’t publicly validated, tools like SSL Labs or internal vulnerability scanners can help confirm correct installation, cipher support, and potential weaknesses.

5. Common Issues to Watch For

• Hostname Mismatch: If your CN/SAN doesn’t match the address you’re using, browsers will still flag errors.
  
• CA Not Installed: If you skipped distributing the CA, clients won’t trust the certificate.
  
• Expired Certificate: If you set a short lifetime and forgot to renew, pfSense will revert to warnings.

Validation is not a one-time step; it should be repeated periodically or whenever you update certificates. Proper testing guarantees that your pfSense HTTPS certificate is functioning as intended, giving you confidence in both security and usability.

MORE: Can I Use pfSense As A DNS Server​?

Automating Renewal and Maintenance

Creating and assigning an SSL certificate in pfSense is only the beginning. To maintain secure access, you must ensure that certificates don’t expire unexpectedly. A single expired certificate can lock you out of the WebGUI or flood your users with browser warnings. This is why automation and proactive maintenance are essential.

1. Why Renewal Matters

SSL certificates have a set validity period. Internal certificates you generate may last several years, but shorter lifetimes are more secure. Without a proper renewal process, your pfSense HTTPS certificate will eventually expire, causing service disruption.

2. Manual vs. Automated Renewal

• Manual Renewal: You revisit System > Cert Manager, generate a new certificate, and reassign it. While straightforward, it’s easy to forget.
  
• Automated Renewal: pfSense supports automation through the ACME protocol, which is widely used by Let’s Encrypt. With ACME, pfSense can automatically renew certificates without human intervention.

3. Using Let’s Encrypt with pfSense

If your firewall has a public domain name, you can configure the pfSense SSL certificate with Let’s Encrypt:

• Install the ACME package in pfSense.
  
• Configure a domain (e.g., firewall.example.com) with a DNS challenge or HTTP validation.
  
• pfSense will request a certificate from Let’s Encrypt and renew it automatically every 90 days.

This is ideal for firewalls that need browser-trusted certificates for external access.

4. Internal Certificates and Renewal Strategy

If you rely on an internal CA for private networks:

• Set a reasonably long lifetime when creating certificates (1–3 years).
  
• Maintain a renewal calendar and reminders.
  
• Consider automating renewal scripts or packages within pfSense to reissue and reassign certificates before they expire.

5. Monitoring and Alerts

Even with automation, monitoring is critical. pfSense can log certificate events, and you can set up notifications via email to alert you when a renewal fails or a certificate is close to expiration.

6. Best Practice Tip

Combine internal SSL certificates for internal-only access with Let’s Encrypt for public-facing services. This hybrid approach ensures local flexibility while keeping global browsers happy.

By automating certificate renewal, whether with pfSense ACME + Let’s Encrypt or a well-planned internal process, you reduce administrative overhead, avoid service interruptions, and guarantee continuous secure access to the WebGUI.

READ: pfSense Plus Vs CE: A Comprehensive Analysis

Troubleshooting Common Problems

Even after carefully setting up SSL certificates in pfSense, you may encounter issues that prevent a smooth, secure login. Most of these problems are easy to diagnose once you know what to look for. Below are some of the most common scenarios and their solutions.

1. Browser Still Shows Security Warnings

• Cause: The root CA was not installed on the client device.
  
• Fix: Export the internal CA from pfSense and import it into the Trusted Root Certification Authorities store on Windows or into the CA certificates section on Android.

2. Hostname or IP Mismatch

• Cause: The Common Name (CN) or Subject Alternative Names (SANs) do not match the address you are using. For example, the certificate may list pfsense.local but you are connecting via 192.168.1.1.
  
• Fix: Recreate the certificate with both the hostname and IP address added under SAN.

3. WebConfigurator Not Loading After Certificate Change

• Cause: The assigned certificate is invalid or not properly linked to the WebGUI.
  
• Fix: Access pfSense via SSH or the console. Navigate to System > Advanced > Admin Access from another session and reassign the default certificate to restore WebGUI access.

4. Expired Certificates

• Cause: Manual renewal was overlooked.
  
• Fix: Renew the certificate via Cert Manager and assign the new one. To prevent recurrence, configure automated renewal with the ACME package (for Let’s Encrypt) or schedule reminders for internal certificates.

5. Private Key Mismatch

• Cause: The certificate and private key do not pair correctly. This often happens when importing certificates generated outside pfSense.
  
• Fix: Regenerate the CSR and private key inside pfSense, then reissue the certificate.

6. Let’s Encrypt Renewal Failure

• Cause: DNS validation or port access issues when pfSense tries to renew a certificate.
  
• Fix: Check DNS CAA records, ensure the correct validation method is used (DNS vs. HTTP), and verify firewall rules allow the challenge traffic.

7. Android Clients Still Show Warnings

• Cause: Some Android versions require CA certificates to be installed as system certificates rather than user certificates for full trust.
  
• Fix: Reinstall the CA at the system level, or use a public CA like Let’s Encrypt for wider compatibility.

Best Practices for SSL in pfSense

Securing your pfSense firewall with SSL certificates is more than just creating and assigning one certificate. To ensure long-term reliability, you need to follow a set of best practices that minimize risks and maximize trust.

1. Use Strong Keys and Algorithms

Always generate certificates with RSA 2048-bit or higher and use SHA256 or stronger digest algorithms. Shorter keys or outdated algorithms like SHA1 can be vulnerable to cryptographic attacks.

2. Secure the Private Key

The private key is the backbone of your SSL setup. If it’s compromised, attackers can impersonate your firewall. Restrict administrative access, and never export or share the private key outside pfSense unless absolutely necessary.

3. Assign Unique Certificates per Firewall

Avoid the temptation to reuse the same certificate across multiple pfSense firewalls. If one system is compromised, reusing certificates multiplies the risk. Each firewall should have its own pfSense webConfigurator certificate for better security and traceability.

4. Monitor Expiration Dates

Even with long lifetimes, certificates will eventually expire. Set reminders or use pfSense’s notification system to alert you 30–60 days before expiration. Pair this with automated renewal where possible.

5. Validate the Full Certificate Chain

A certificate is only as strong as its trust chain. Always include intermediate certificates when importing and validate using OpenSSL or SSL chain-check tools. This prevents trust errors in different browsers or devices.

6. Regularly Audit SSL Settings

Perform routine SSL audits on pfSense to confirm encryption strength, certificate trust, and expiration status. Online tools and internal scanners can help you identify weak ciphers or outdated configurations.

7. Establish Revocation Procedures

If a certificate or private key is ever compromised, you must revoke it immediately. Use Certificate Revocation Lists (CRLs) or the Online Certificate Status Protocol (OCSP) to invalidate compromised certificates and issue replacements quickly.

Conclusion

Creating an internal SSL certificate for your pfSense firewall is beyond avoiding browser warnings; you need to build a trusted and encrypted environment for managing one of the most critical components of your network. 

By setting up a pfSense certificate authority, generating a server certificate, assigning it to the WebConfigurator, and distributing the CA to your client devices, you’ve established a secure workflow that protects your administrative access.

For internal-only networks, this approach eliminates reliance on external providers while giving you full control. For firewalls with public-facing access, combining internal certificates with options like pfSense SSL certificate Let’s Encrypt ensures that both internal and external connections remain secure and trusted.

The real power lies in ongoing management: monitoring expiration dates, automating renewals, validating certificate chains, and having clear revocation procedures. With these practices in place, you’re not just installing a pfSense HTTPS certificate — you’re actively maintaining a strong security posture that defends against eavesdropping, tampering, and unauthorized access.

FAQ