What Is the Difference Between EDR and SIEM?

When it comes to cybersecurity, organizations face increasing challenges to protect sensitive data and systems from advanced threats. Among the tools and strategies available, two critical technologies stand out: Security Information and Event Management (SIEM) and Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR).

These two solutions play pivotal roles in an organization’s security infrastructure, but understanding their differences and how they complement each other can significantly improve an organization’s defense mechanisms.

While both SIEM and EDR are designed to detect and respond to security threats, their core functionalities, focus areas, and approaches to managing incidents differ. Understanding these distinctions, along with how SIEM works with other solutions like XDR (Extended Detection and Response) and SOAR (Security Orchestration, Automation, and Response), is essential for building a comprehensive cybersecurity strategy.

In this article, we will answer the question: What is the difference between EDR and SIEM, how they interact, and how combining both can provide more robust protection. Additionally, we will address the integration of other technologies like XDR, the role of file integrity monitoring in EDR, and how EDR compares to traditional antivirus solutions.

If you’re ready to take the next step in your tech career journey, cybersecurity is the simplest and high-paying field to start from. Apart from earning 6-figures from the comfort of your home, you don’t need to have a degree or IT background. Schedule a one-on-one consultation session with our expert cybersecurity coach, Tolulope Michael TODAY! Join over 1000 students in sharing your success stories.

EDR and SIEM: Comparison Table

Feature	SIEM	EDR
Scope of Coverage	Network-wide	Endpoint-specific
Primary Focus	Event aggregation and analysis across the network (servers, network devices, databases)	Endpoint threat detection, behavioral analysis, and response
Response Capabilities	Alert generation, manual investigation and response	Automated response capabilities (e.g., isolating devices, killing processes)
Data Collection	Collects data from network devices, servers, applications, etc.	Collects data from endpoints (desktops, laptops, mobile devices)
Event Correlation	Analyzes and correlates events across the network	Behavioral analysis at the endpoint level
Automation	Limited automation, mostly for alerts and investigations	High automation, including response and remediation
Use Case	Compliance monitoring, threat detection, and network security oversight	Protecting endpoints from ransomware, APTs, zero-day exploits, etc.
Ideal For	Organizations needing compliance, visibility, and network-wide security monitoring	Organizations focusing on endpoint protection and rapid response to threats

RELATED ARTICLE: EDR Vs NDR: A Comprehensive Analysis

What Is SIEM?

Security Information and Event Management (SIEM) is a technology that provides a comprehensive view of an organization’s entire security posture. Its primary role is to aggregate, analyze, and store security-related data from across various systems within the network, such as servers, network devices, databases, and security tools. 

By offering this macro-level view of security events, SIEM systems play an essential role in helping organizations monitor security, ensure compliance, and identify potential threats before they can cause significant damage.

At its core, SIEM involves two critical functions: security information management (SIM) and security event management (SEM). The SIM component collects and stores logs from various devices and systems across the organization, while SEM focuses on real-time analysis of security events and alerts, providing organizations with the ability to respond quickly to potential incidents.

Some of the key features of SIEM tools include:

• Log aggregation from multiple sources: SIEM collects logs and event data from a wide range of sources across the network, providing a centralized location for security analysis.
  
• Event correlation and anomaly detection: SIEM tools use pre-defined rules and algorithms to correlate different security events, identifying patterns that might indicate a security breach or unusual activity.
  
• Real-time alerting: SIEM generates alerts for security teams when potential threats are detected, enabling immediate attention and response.
  
• Historical data analysis for compliance: SIEM systems store and analyze historical data, which is vital for regulatory compliance, auditing, and forensic investigations.

The primary value of SIEM is its ability to give security professionals a holistic view of the entire organization’s network security. This helps organizations monitor for compliance, detect intrusions, and investigate incidents across a broad range of systems and networks, providing a crucial layer of oversight.

READ MORE: Managed Network Detection and Response​: Everything You Need to Know

What is EDR?

Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) is a cybersecurity solution designed to monitor, detect, and respond to threats specifically at the endpoint level. Unlike SIEM, which focuses on network-wide security, EDR is tailored to protect individual devices such as laptops, desktops, servers, and mobile devices. 

As organizations increasingly rely on endpoints for day-to-day operations, securing these devices has become paramount in defending against advanced cyber threats.

EDR solutions are equipped with real-time monitoring capabilities, continuously analyzing activities on endpoints to detect suspicious behavior or indicators of a security breach. 

They employ a range of techniques, including behavioral analysis and machine learning, to spot threats that may not be detectable by traditional antivirus solutions. When a potential threat is identified, EDR solutions can generate alerts, record detailed data about the event, and even take immediate action to contain the threat.

Some of the key features of EDR include:

• Continuous endpoint monitoring: EDR solutions continuously track endpoint activities, providing real-time visibility into user and system behavior.
  
• Behavioral analysis: By analyzing the normal behavior of endpoints, EDR can detect anomalies that may indicate the presence of malware or other malicious activities.
  
• Automated response capabilities: Once a threat is detected, EDR can respond automatically by isolating the infected endpoint, killing malicious processes, or quarantining suspicious files.
  
• Forensic tools: EDR tools collect and store detailed information on incidents, allowing security teams to conduct in-depth post-incident investigations and determine the root cause of the attack.

EDR is important in defending against advanced, sophisticated threats that often bypass traditional security measures, such as ransomware, zero-day exploits, and advanced persistent threats (APTs). It provides endpoint visibility, quick response capabilities, and post-incident analysis to ensure that organizations can quickly detect and neutralize threats at the device level.

SEE ALSO: Cyber Security Vs Web Development​: A Complete Analysis

SIEM vs EDR

When comparing SIEM (Security Information and Event Management) and EDR (Endpoint Detection and Response), it’s important to recognize that although both play vital roles in a cybersecurity strategy, they serve distinct purposes and operate at different levels.

Purpose and Scope

• SIEM provides a broad, macro-level view of security across the entire organization. It aggregates and analyzes data from various sources such as network devices, servers, databases, and other IT systems. SIEM focuses on network-wide monitoring, event correlation, compliance reporting, and alert generation. Its primary goal is to give security teams an overarching view of security events, helping them spot potential threats across the entire network.
  
• EDR, on the other hand, zooms in on endpoints, such as user devices, laptops, desktops, and servers. EDR is primarily concerned with monitoring, detecting, and responding to threats at the device level. Unlike SIEM, EDR provides real-time behavioral analysis of endpoint activity, detecting and mitigating attacks directly on those devices.

Response and Remediation

• SIEM generates alerts based on analyzed data, but often requires manual intervention for incident response. While it excels in detecting patterns, correlating events, and providing visibility into network-wide security, it doesn’t have the same response capabilities as EDR. SIEM alerts may lead to an investigation, but the action is typically carried out by security teams or other integrated tools.
  
• EDR, however, offers automated threat containment. If a suspicious activity or potential breach is detected on an endpoint, EDR can take immediate actions such as isolating the device, killing malicious processes, or quarantining infected files. This makes EDR more efficient for real-time threat mitigation and automated incident response at the endpoint level.

Data Collection and Analysis

• SIEM collects data from a wide variety of sources across the network. It normalizes and correlates this data to provide a holistic view of the organization’s security posture. By analyzing event logs and identifying unusual patterns, SIEM helps security teams track suspicious activity across the network.
  
• EDR focuses specifically on endpoint data. It monitors endpoint activity, records system-level behaviors, and applies machine learning and behavioral analytics to identify anomalies. Granular, device-level analysis in EDR gives security teams deeper insight into potential threats that may not be visible at the network level.

Use Cases

• SIEM is particularly beneficial for organizations needing compliance management, incident detection, and network-wide security oversight. It is often deployed in environments where comprehensive monitoring, regulatory compliance, and centralized logging are priorities. SIEM is ideal for detecting insider threats, network breaches, and unusual activity patterns across the entire infrastructure.
• EDR is most effective for organizations that prioritize endpoint security. EDR is critical in defending against attacks that target specific devices, such as ransomware, zero-day exploits, and advanced persistent threats. It is particularly useful for organizations where real-time response to endpoint threats is essential.

SIEM vs XDR

Extended Detection and Response (XDR) is a newer and more advanced cybersecurity solution that builds upon the functionalities of EDR by providing a more integrated and unified approach to threat detection and response across multiple security layers, endpoint, network, and cloud. While both SIEM and XDR are critical in modern cybersecurity strategies, they focus on different aspects and complement each other in a layered defense system.

Key Differences Between SIEM and XDR

• Scope and Integration:
  
  • SIEM provides a centralized platform for aggregating and analyzing security data from multiple sources across the network, including servers, devices, applications, and databases. Its focus is on event correlation and log management from these diverse sources. SIEM is designed to offer a macro-level view of security, identifying threats across the entire network.
    
  • XDR, however, takes a more holistic approach by integrating threat detection and response capabilities across multiple security layers, endpoints, networks, cloud, and sometimes even email systems. XDR unifies various data sources into one platform, providing a more comprehensive view of an organization’s security landscape, especially when dealing with multi-vector threats that span different domains.
    
• Automation and Response:
  
  • SIEM is focused more on threat detection, event correlation, and alerting, requiring manual intervention for incident response. While SIEM tools generate alerts based on the data they collect and analyze, they generally do not automate the response to security incidents.
    
  • XDR, on the other hand, is designed for automated incident response. It not only detects threats but also takes action to contain them across multiple layers of security. This can include automated responses such as blocking malicious traffic, isolating endpoints, or stopping suspicious processes across the network. XDR combines detection with response in one seamless system.

How XDR Enhances SIEM

While SIEM is excellent at providing a high-level view of security across the entire network, XDR takes this a step further by providing more granular data and faster response times. By integrating threat data from endpoints, networks, and cloud environments, XDR enhances SIEM’s capabilities by providing security teams with richer, more detailed insights into potential threats.

For example, a SIEM system might generate an alert about unusual network traffic, but it wouldn’t provide the context of which endpoint initiated that traffic. XDR, however, can provide a full context, detailing not only the network activity but also the specific endpoint involved, the behavior of the device, and even the cloud activity associated with the threat. This contextual data helps security teams act more quickly and accurately.

Moreover, XDR’s integration with SIEM allows the two systems to work together. While SIEM aggregates and analyzes data from various sources, XDR acts as an extension of that data, offering real-time detection, automation, and more detailed forensic capabilities. Together, these solutions create a powerful, integrated approach to cybersecurity.

MORE: MDR Vs XDR Cybersecurity (MDR Vs EDR Cybersecurity): A Complete Analysis

SIEM vs SOAR

Security Orchestration, Automation, and Response (SOAR) is another important technology in the modern cybersecurity landscape. While SIEM and SOAR both play critical roles in threat detection and response, they serve complementary functions and often work best when integrated together.

Key Differences Between SIEM and SOAR

• Focus and Purpose:
  
  • SIEM focuses on security event aggregation, analysis, and reporting. It collects data from various security tools across the network, correlates events, and generates alerts when potential threats are detected. SIEM is primarily used for monitoring, compliance, log management, and threat detection.
    
  • SOAR, on the other hand, focuses on automating the incident response process. It allows organizations to streamline and automate tasks, orchestrating security workflows and responses across different security tools. SOAR can automate manual tasks, such as alert triage, incident management, and response actions, thereby reducing the time between threat detection and remediation.
    
• Automation and Response:
  
  • SIEM generates alerts based on the analysis of event logs and security data but often requires manual intervention to investigate and respond to threats. While it helps identify potential security incidents, it doesn’t offer a significant level of automation for remediation.
    
  • SOAR excels at automating responses to security alerts. It allows organizations to define automated workflows and playbooks that can instantly contain or mitigate security threats. For instance, a SOAR platform can automatically block malicious IP addresses, quarantine infected files, or even trigger incident reports based on predefined rules.

How SIEM and SOAR Work Together

While SIEM is excellent at detecting and alerting on security events, SOAR takes over when it comes to responding and orchestrating the actions needed to address those alerts. Together, these technologies provide a more efficient and effective security framework.

Here’s how they complement each other:

• SIEM detects the threat and generates an alert.
  
• SOAR automatically initiates a predefined response to that alert, whether it’s isolating a compromised system, blocking a malicious IP address, or triggering an incident response workflow.
  
• SIEM logs the details of the incident for compliance reporting and forensics, while SOAR handles the operational aspect of response, ensuring that the organization reacts quickly and efficiently.

By using SIEM for detection and SOAR for response, organizations can reduce response times, minimize the impact of attacks, and enhance their security posture through a more efficient and integrated approach.

READ: What Does C2 Mean in Cyber Security?

The Role of File Integrity Monitoring (FIM) in EDR

File Integrity Monitoring (FIM) is a critical component of Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) solutions, playing a key role in detecting potential security threats at the device level. The primary purpose of FIM is to monitor changes to files and system configurations on endpoints, ensuring that any unauthorized modifications are immediately flagged for review.

What is FIM?

FIM is a process that tracks the integrity of files across endpoints by monitoring and recording changes, deletions, or additions to important system files. These files often include configurations, application files, and system executables that are integral to the operation of the system. Any unexpected changes to these files, whether due to malicious activity, malware, or human error, can indicate a potential security breach or compromise.

The File Integrity Monitoring (FIM) Module in EDR is Responsible For:

• Tracking File Changes: The FIM module continuously monitors specified files or directories for changes, such as alterations to file contents or unexpected deletions. Any unauthorized modification triggers an alert for immediate review by security teams.
  
• Detecting Malicious Activity: Since malware and other malicious programs often alter system files to evade detection, FIM helps identify such activities. For instance, malware may attempt to modify executable files or system configurations to maintain persistence. By monitoring these files, FIM can quickly detect abnormal behaviors that may indicate an active attack.
  
• Providing Forensic Evidence: In the event of a security incident, FIM provides security teams with detailed logs and historical data about file changes, aiding in forensic investigations. This information is crucial for understanding the scope of the attack and identifying the initial point of compromise.
  
• Preventing Unauthorized Access: FIM helps prevent unauthorized users or attackers from tampering with critical system files or configurations. By maintaining the integrity of these files, FIM ensures that attackers cannot manipulate systems undetected.

How FIM Enhances EDR Capabilities

FIM is particularly useful in preventing and detecting certain types of advanced attacks that specifically target the files on an endpoint. When integrated into an EDR solution, FIM contributes to overall endpoint security by ensuring that files and configurations remain intact, alerting security teams to potential threats before they escalate.

For example, ransomware often attempts to encrypt critical files on an endpoint, effectively locking users out of their systems. A robust FIM system will monitor these files and immediately flag any attempts to alter or encrypt them, enabling security teams to take action before the ransomware can cause significant damage.

By offering file-level visibility, FIM allows EDR to better detect sophisticated threats, making it an indispensable tool for improving endpoint security.

SEE: 2025 Incident Response GRC Interview Questions​ for Beginners

EDR vs Antivirus

In the realm of cybersecurity, Antivirus and Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) are both tools designed to protect endpoints, such as desktops, laptops, and mobile devices, from malicious threats. However, their approaches, capabilities, and levels of protection differ significantly.

Antivirus: The Traditional Approach

Antivirus software has long been a staple in cybersecurity, offering basic protection against known threats. Traditional antivirus relies heavily on signature-based detection, which involves scanning files and programs for signatures (unique patterns) associated with known malware. This method is effective at identifying and blocking threats that have been previously cataloged, such as viruses, trojans, and worms.

• Detection Focus: Antivirus tools primarily look for known malicious files based on pre-defined signatures.
  
• Response: When a known threat is detected, antivirus software typically quarantines the malicious file or deletes it to prevent further harm.
  
• Protection Type: Antivirus provides a basic layer of protection and is generally more reactive, focusing on preventing well-known malware from affecting the system.

EDR: Advanced, Proactive Protection

Unlike antivirus, EDR solutions go beyond simple signature-based detection. EDR uses more advanced techniques, including behavioral analysis and machine learning, to detect threats based on abnormal behavior rather than just known signatures. This allows EDR to identify new, previously unseen threats, such as zero-day attacks and advanced persistent threats (APTs).

• Detection Focus: EDR looks for abnormal endpoint behavior and suspicious patterns, even if the threat has never been encountered before.
  
• Response: EDR offers automated response capabilities, such as isolating the infected device, killing malicious processes, or quarantining compromised files. It can respond in real-time, stopping an attack as it unfolds.
  
• Protection Type: EDR provides a more comprehensive, proactive approach to endpoint protection. It offers continuous monitoring, real-time threat detection, and automated remediation.

Why EDR is More Effective than Antivirus

While antivirus provides a fundamental level of security, its reliance on signatures means that it can miss new and evolving threats. Modern cyberattacks, such as ransomware and sophisticated fileless malware, can bypass traditional antivirus detection methods.

On the other hand, EDR is designed to handle these more advanced threats by monitoring system behaviors continuously. It can detect anomalies, such as suspicious file access or unusual network traffic, even if the specific threat has never been seen before. This gives EDR a significant advantage in defending against emerging threats.

Furthermore, EDR’s automated remediation capabilities mean that threats can be contained and mitigated in real-time, something that antivirus cannot do as efficiently.

The Relationship Between Antivirus and EDR

Rather than viewing antivirus and EDR as mutually exclusive, organizations should see them as complementary technologies. Antivirus remains an important tool for blocking well-known, traditional malware, while EDR provides the necessary layer of protection to detect, respond to, and mitigate advanced threats that antivirus might miss.

In an ideal cybersecurity strategy, both antivirus and EDR work together to provide a multi-layered defense for endpoints, with antivirus catching known threats and EDR providing deeper, proactive protection for emerging and sophisticated attacks.

Choosing the Right Solution for Your Organization

When it comes to building a robust cybersecurity infrastructure, choosing the right security solutions is paramount. While both SIEM and EDR play critical roles in protecting your organization, the decision to use one or both depends on your specific security needs and the nature of your business. Here’s how to decide which solution, or combination of solutions, best fits your organization’s goals.

When to Use SIEM

SIEM is ideal for organizations that require:

• Comprehensive Security Monitoring: If your organization handles sensitive data, deals with large volumes of transactions, or needs oversight across a wide network of devices and systems, SIEM will provide a holistic view of your entire network’s security. It is particularly useful in highly regulated industries that need to comply with standards like GDPR, HIPAA, or PCI-DSS.
  
• Compliance Management: If your business is subject to compliance requirements, SIEM provides valuable tools for log management and automated compliance reporting. SIEM systems retain historical data, making it easier for organizations to demonstrate compliance during audits.
  
• Incident Detection Across the Network: If your organization needs to detect threats on a macro level, across servers, databases, applications, and other infrastructure, SIEM is the solution for providing visibility into security events across the entire network.

When to Use EDR

EDR is essential when your organization needs:

• Endpoint-Focused Protection: If your business relies heavily on endpoints, like laptops, desktops, mobile devices, and remote workers, EDR is critical for providing detailed security at the individual device level. With the rise of remote work and BYOD (bring-your-own-device) policies, EDR is especially important in detecting threats that target these devices.
  
• Real-Time Response: If your organization requires immediate containment and remediation of threats, EDR provides real-time visibility and automated responses. This is especially valuable when facing advanced threats like ransomware or zero-day exploits that require quick mitigation.
  
• Behavioral Detection: EDR is better equipped to detect advanced persistent threats (APTs) or fileless malware by analyzing endpoint behaviors and patterns. This makes it an ideal solution for environments where security risks are constantly evolving and traditional signature-based antivirus solutions are not enough.

Combining SIEM and EDR for Maximum Protection

For most organizations, the best approach is to integrate both SIEM and EDR. Each tool excels in different areas, and combining them can help create a more comprehensive and resilient security framework. Here’s why:

• SIEM provides a macro-level overview of network-wide security, identifying patterns and correlations that may indicate broader attacks or vulnerabilities.
  
• EDR, meanwhile, provides granular, endpoint-level visibility and real-time response capabilities, detecting and mitigating threats that may go unnoticed at the network level.

By integrating these two solutions, organizations can gain both visibility and control, allowing for better threat detection, investigation, and response. For example, SIEM might detect unusual activity across the network, and EDR can be used to respond to and investigate those activities at the endpoint level.

How to Evaluate Your Needs

When choosing between SIEM, EDR, or a combination of both, consider the following factors:

• Scale and Complexity: Larger organizations with complex networks and diverse systems will likely benefit from both SIEM and EDR for comprehensive security.
  
• Regulatory Requirements: Businesses in highly regulated industries should prioritize SIEM for compliance purposes, while also using EDR for robust endpoint protection.
  
• Threats: If your organization faces a high risk of endpoint-targeted attacks, EDR should be a priority. If you need a broader overview of network security, SIEM is essential.
  
• Budget and Resources: SIEM solutions can be resource-intensive and may require specialized personnel to manage effectively. EDR tends to focus more on endpoint protection, making it easier to deploy on a smaller scale or for specific use cases.

FAQ