Cybersecurity Audit Certificate Vs CISA: A Comprehensive Analysis

Security auditing has become important for organizations to ensure their systems and processes are secure, compliant, and resilient. With rising cyber threats and an increased focus on data protection, professionals in this field need to be equipped with both the knowledge and certifications to stand out in a competitive job market. 

Two prominent certifications in this domain are the Certified Information Systems Auditor (CISA) and the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate offered by ISACA.

While both certifications hold merit, they cater to different aspects of cybersecurity auditing.

This article critically examines the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate vs CISA certification, comparing them in terms of purpose, scope, difficulty, and career impact. 

Cybersecurity Audit Certificate Vs CISA: Comparison Table

RELATED: Information Assurance Vs Cybersecurity: Everything You Need to Know

What is CISA Certification?

The Certified Information Systems Auditor (CISA) certification, offered by ISACA, is a globally recognized credential that has become the gold standard for professionals in IT auditing, control, and security. It is designed to validate the expertise of individuals in auditing information systems, managing IT risks, and ensuring that the necessary controls are in place to protect organizational assets.

Key Domains of CISA

The CISA certification covers five essential domains, each focusing on critical aspects of information systems auditing:

1. The Process of Auditing Information Systems (18%)
   This domain focuses on understanding audit processes, how to assess risks, and how to plan and execute audits effectively.
2. Governance and Management of IT (18%)
   Auditors must ensure that IT governance structures align with the organization’s goals, and this domain tests knowledge of management practices, enterprise architecture, and IT policies.
3. Information Systems Acquisition, Development, and Implementation (12%)
   This section covers business cases, feasibility analysis, and system development methodologies, ensuring that auditors understand how new systems are implemented and their impact on risk.
4. Information Systems Operations and Business Resilience (26%)
   Emphasizing the need for strong operational security, this domain tests knowledge of business continuity planning, disaster recovery, and information systems operations.
5. Protection of Information Assets (26%)
   The final domain ensures that candidates understand how to safeguard an organization’s data, focusing on access controls, incident management, and security measures.

CISA Work Experience Requirements

To earn the CISA certification, candidates must have at least five years of relevant professional experience in information systems auditing, control, or security. However, ISACA offers certain educational waivers for up to three years of this requirement, depending on academic qualifications.

CISA Certification Exam Format

The CISA certification exam consists of 150 multiple-choice questions covering the five domains mentioned above. Candidates have four hours to complete the exam, and they must achieve a minimum passing score of 450 (out of 800).

CISA Certification Cost

The CISA certification cost varies based on membership status. ISACA members pay $575, while non-members must pay $760 to take the exam.

CISA Certification Salary

Professionals holding the CISA certification often enjoy competitive salaries, with the average salary in the U.S. reported to be over $145,000 as of 2023. The certification demonstrates expertise in IT governance and audit practices, making it highly desirable for positions such as IT auditors, risk managers, and information security officers.

READ MORE: Best Free Cybersecurity Resources for You

The Cybersecurity Audit Certificate

The Cybersecurity Audit Certificate, also offered by ISACA, is specifically designed for professionals who want to focus on auditing within the field of cybersecurity. While it shares similarities with the CISA certification, it zeroes in on the nuances of cybersecurity governance, operations, and the role of audits in safeguarding systems from emerging threats.

What is the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate?

The Cybersecurity Audit Certificate validates a professional’s ability to assess and audit an organization’s cybersecurity framework. Unlike the broader scope of CISA, this certification is tailored to individuals who need to ensure that cybersecurity measures are both compliant and effective. It is a great fit for IT auditors, cybersecurity specialists, and risk professionals who aim to concentrate on auditing cybersecurity controls rather than general IT systems.

Key Areas Covered in the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate

The Cybersecurity Audit Certificate program encompasses four core domains:

1. Cybersecurity Governance (20%)
   This domain tests the auditor’s ability to evaluate the effectiveness of an organization’s cybersecurity governance framework, ensuring alignment with regulatory requirements and risk management practices.
2. Cybersecurity Operations (45%)
   The largest section of the exam focuses on cybersecurity operational practices, including monitoring, incident management, and ongoing risk assessments. Auditors need to understand how these operations contribute to the organization’s overall security posture.
3. Technology Topics (30%)
   Here, the focus is on understanding emerging technologies like cloud computing, artificial intelligence, and the Internet of Things (IoT), and how these technologies influence an organization’s cybersecurity risks.
4. Audit’s Role in Cybersecurity (5%)
   This domain emphasizes the auditor’s responsibility in evaluating the adequacy and effectiveness of cybersecurity controls, ensuring that audit findings contribute to better security practices.

Cybersecurity Audit Certificate Exam Structure

The Cybersecurity Audit Certificate exam consists of 75 multiple-choice questions. It is a two-hour exam, and candidates need to score at least 65% to pass. The exam is conducted remotely and proctored online, allowing candidates to take it from the convenience of their home or office.

Cybersecurity Audit Certificate Exam Cost

The cybersecurity audit certificate exam cost varies based on the training and study bundle chosen. The total cost typically includes the study guide, training (self-paced or instructor-led), and the exam itself. While specific prices fluctuate depending on the training format, retakes cost $249 for ISACA members and $299 for non-members.

ALSO SEE: Cybersecurity Engineer Vs Analyst: Everything You Need to Know

CISA vs Cybersecurity Audit Certificate: Detailed Comparison

When considering the CISA certification and the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate, it’s essential to understand the differences in scope, target audience, and career impact. While both certifications are valuable in the field of IT auditing, each caters to different professional paths and needs.

Target Audience

The CISA certification is designed for professionals who work in general IT auditing, governance, and control, covering a broad spectrum of information systems and risk management. 

It is ideal for individuals aiming to pursue careers in IT auditing across various industries, with a focus on IT governance, operational resilience, and information security management.

On the other hand, the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate is more specialized, targeting professionals who focus on auditing cybersecurity controls and processes specifically. 

This certification is better suited for individuals already working in or transitioning to roles centered on cybersecurity, such as cybersecurity auditors, IT risk managers, and cybersecurity specialists. It hones in on how to audit and assess cybersecurity governance, operations, and technologies.

Exam Difficulty

When comparing the CISA vs CIA difficulty, both certifications present their own challenges. The CISA exam is known for its comprehensive nature, covering five domains that encompass the entire landscape of IT auditing, including governance, management of IT, and business continuity. 

With 150 questions and a required passing score of 450, the exam is designed to be rigorous and tests a candidate’s depth of knowledge in information systems.

The Cybersecurity Audit Certificate exam, while shorter at 75 questions, requires a focused understanding of cybersecurity-specific domains. Its difficulty comes from the necessity to understand emerging technologies, operations, and specific cybersecurity risks. 

While the CISA exam might be broader in scope, the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate requires a specialized knowledge base, particularly in evolving technologies like cloud computing and AI.

Certification Maintenance and Continuing Education

Both certifications require ongoing education to maintain their validity. The CISA certification requires professionals to earn 20 hours of continuing professional education (CPE) annually and a minimum of 120 hours every three years. This ensures that professionals stay updated on evolving practices in IT auditing and information systems security.

For the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate, ISACA mandates completing a similar number of CPE hours to keep the certification active, although the focus is more on the latest developments in cybersecurity.

Industry Demand and Recognition

The CISA certification is a globally recognized credential that is highly valued across industries such as finance, healthcare, and technology. It is considered the gold standard for IT auditors and is frequently a job requirement for roles in IT governance, risk management, and security auditing.

The Cybersecurity Audit Certificate, while newer, is gaining traction in cybersecurity-focused industries due to the rising emphasis on cyber risk management and security audits. Given the growing number of cyberattacks and data breaches, the demand for professionals with specific expertise in auditing cybersecurity frameworks is increasing rapidly.

Isaca Cybersecurity Audit Certificate Worth It?

For professionals who are specifically focused on cybersecurity auditing, the ISACA Cybersecurity Audit Certificate is certainly worth it. It offers niche skills that are becoming highly sought after as organizations prioritize cybersecurity in their operations. 

Compared to the broader CISA, it provides more focused training on cybersecurity risks and audit practices, making it a valuable credential for individuals targeting cybersecurity roles.

READ: CISSP Vs CISM: A Comprehensive Analysis

Career Prospects and Salary Potential

When comparing the CISA certification and the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate, understanding their impact on career prospects and salaries is crucial. Both certifications can open doors to lucrative and fulfilling career paths in IT auditing and cybersecurity, but each offers different advantages depending on your career goals.

Cybersecurity Audit Certificate Salary

Professionals with the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate tend to pursue roles that are directly involved in evaluating and auditing an organization’s cybersecurity measures. Roles such as cybersecurity auditor, IT risk analyst, and cybersecurity specialist are common for holders of this certification.

According to industry reports, the cyber security auditor salary varies based on experience, location, and industry. On average, cybersecurity auditors earn between $90,000 and $120,000 annually in the U.S., with salaries reaching even higher figures in cybersecurity-heavy industries like finance and healthcare. 

This certification helps professionals focus on niche cybersecurity risks, which is becoming increasingly valuable in sectors facing stringent data protection regulations.

CISA vs Cybersecurity Audit Certificate Salary Comparison

While both certifications offer competitive salary prospects, professionals holding the CISA certification generally have a broader range of career opportunities. CISA-certified individuals often pursue roles such as IT auditor, compliance manager, or information systems security manager. 

These roles can command higher salaries, with the CISA certification salary averaging between $100,000 and $145,000 per year in the U.S. Salaries can rise even higher for experienced professionals or those in leadership positions like chief information security officer (CISO) or director of IT audit.

Comparatively, while the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate is valuable, it is more specialized, which might limit its application to cybersecurity-focused roles. However, as demand for cybersecurity expertise continues to grow, this certification is increasingly recognized, especially in industries like finance and healthcare where cybersecurity threats are more prevalent.

CISA vs CIA Salary

It’s also important to briefly consider the comparison between CISA vs CIA salary (Certified Internal Auditor). While both certifications are highly regarded, the CISA often commands higher salaries due to its focus on IT systems and cybersecurity, fields that generally offer higher compensation than internal financial auditing. 

On average, a CIA professional earns between $85,000 and $110,000, slightly less than their CISA counterparts.

Salary Influencers

Several factors influence the salary potential for professionals with either certification:

• Experience Level: The more experience in IT audit or cybersecurity, the higher the salary.
• Industry: Sectors like finance, healthcare, and technology typically pay more due to the critical nature of their IT systems and the need for robust cybersecurity measures.
• Geographic Location: Professionals in major tech hubs or regions with higher costs of living often earn more.

SEE: Most In Demand Cybersecurity Certifications, Most Valuable Cybersecurity Certifications

Key Considerations in Choosing Between CISA and Cybersecurity Audit Certificate

When deciding between the CISA certification and the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate, it’s essential to consider several key factors that align with your career goals, current experience, and industry demand. Each certification offers unique benefits, and the right choice depends on what you aim to achieve in your professional journey.

Career Goals and Job Roles

One of the first steps in choosing between these certifications is identifying your specific career objectives. The CISA certification is ideal for professionals who want to pursue roles in general IT auditing, governance, and risk management. 

This certification provides broad, comprehensive knowledge applicable across a variety of industries, including finance, healthcare, manufacturing, and technology. Roles such as IT auditor, risk manager, and information systems security manager are common career paths for CISA holders.

Conversely, the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate is more specialized and targeted towards individuals who want to focus exclusively on cybersecurity auditing. This certification is suitable for professionals looking to build careers in cybersecurity risk assessment, cyber governance, and auditing security controls. 

Job roles may include cybersecurity auditor, IT risk analyst, and security compliance auditor. If your goal is to work in industries or organizations where cybersecurity is a top priority, such as in finance, healthcare, or government sectors, the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate may be a better fit.

Job Market Demand

The demand for CISA holders has been consistent across industries due to its broad applicability. As organizations increasingly rely on technology for their operations, the need for IT auditors who can ensure compliance and security of information systems continues to grow. 

The CISA certification is also widely recognized and often listed as a prerequisite for high-level IT governance, risk, and compliance roles.

In contrast, the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate is becoming more relevant as cybersecurity risks increase. With the rise of cyberattacks and regulatory requirements for data protection, there is growing demand for professionals who can audit cybersecurity controls specifically. 

The certificate is gaining recognition in industries that are particularly vulnerable to cyber threats, such as healthcare, financial services, and retail. However, the job market for this certificate may be more niche compared to the broader reach of CISA.

Cost and Time Investment

Another important factor to consider is the financial and time investment required for each certification. The CISA certification typically requires more study time due to its broader scope and the depth of knowledge needed to pass the exam. 

The exam consists of 150 questions and requires comprehensive preparation across five domains. Additionally, the work experience requirement (five years) can extend the timeline for obtaining the certification.

The Cybersecurity Audit Certificate, while still demanding, requires less study time and has fewer questions (75) on the exam. The content is more focused on cybersecurity, making it easier to prepare for professionals already familiar with the field. Moreover, it does not have the same stringent work experience requirement, making it accessible to those who may be earlier in their careers or transitioning into cybersecurity auditing.

In terms of cost, the cybersecurity audit certificate exam cost is typically lower than the CISA exam, especially when bundled with study materials and training. Both certifications offer retake options, though the cost of retakes for the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate is slightly lower than for CISA.

Certification Flexibility

The CISA certification is more flexible in terms of job roles and industries it applies to. Professionals who hold this certification can work in a wide range of sectors, from IT governance and compliance to audit and risk management.

The Cybersecurity Audit Certificate, while more specialized, offers deep knowledge in an increasingly critical area. If your goal is to work in cybersecurity-focused roles, especially in industries with high cyber risk exposure, this certificate can set you apart as a specialist in that field.

MORE READ: ​​NIST Cybersecurity Framework Certification

Certification Pathways and Preparation

Preparing for either the CISA certification or the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate requires a strategic approach to studying, understanding the exam format, and choosing the right resources. Both certifications demand a solid understanding of IT systems, auditing practices, and risk management, though they differ in their focus areas.

Preparing for CISA Certification

The CISA certification is a comprehensive credential that covers a broad range of topics, making preparation crucial for success. Here are some steps to effectively prepare:

• Understand the Exam Structure
  The CISA exam consists of 150 multiple-choice questions covering five domains (as detailed earlier). Since each domain carries significant weight, it is essential to allocate study time based on the importance and complexity of each area. For example, areas like Information Systems Operations and Business Resilience and Protection of Information Assets, which together make up over 50% of the exam, should be prioritized in your study plan.
• Create a Study Schedule
  Given the breadth of content in the CISA exam, setting up a structured study plan is crucial. Allocate time each week to review the key domains, focusing on areas where you feel less confident. Start preparation at least 3–6 months before your exam date, depending on your existing knowledge.
• Use ISACA’s Study Resources
  ISACA provides a range of study materials, including the CISA Review Manual, practice exams, and online courses. These resources are designed to cover the full scope of the exam and help candidates familiarize themselves with the types of questions they’ll encounter.
• Join a Study Group
  Many CISA candidates find value in joining online or local study groups. These groups provide support, accountability, and additional perspectives on complex topics. Sharing insights with peers can improve understanding and boost confidence before the exam.
• Take Practice Exams
  Practice exams are one of the most effective ways to prepare. They simulate the actual exam environment and help you gauge your readiness. ISACA offers practice questions and mock exams that align closely with the real CISA exam. Review your performance and focus on improving weak areas.

Preparing for the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate

Preparation for the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate is more focused on cybersecurity-specific auditing and technology topics. Here’s how you can effectively prepare:

• Understand the Exam Structure
  The Cybersecurity Audit Certificate exam consists of 75 multiple-choice questions focusing on four domains. The heaviest weight is on Cybersecurity Operations, making up 45% of the exam. Understanding cybersecurity operations, incident management, and risk mitigation techniques is critical for passing the exam.
• Choose the Right Training Bundle
  The Cybersecurity Audit Certificate is offered as part of a bundle that includes a study guide and training options. ISACA provides self-paced online learning, virtual instructor-led training, and in-person workshops. Choose the format that best fits your learning style and schedule.
• Focus on Emerging Technologies
  Since the exam includes a section on Technology Topics, it’s essential to familiarize yourself with emerging technologies like AI, IoT, and cloud security. Understanding how these technologies impact cybersecurity risks and how to audit them is a crucial aspect of this certification.
• Take Advantage of ISACA’s Study Materials
  Just like with CISA, ISACA offers study guides, practice exams, and training courses specifically for the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate. Ensure you thoroughly review all domains and take practice exams to assess your readiness.
• Practical Application of Concepts
  Since this certification focuses on cybersecurity auditing, practical experience in the field can be beneficial. If you are currently working in a cybersecurity role, try applying the audit techniques you’re learning in real-world scenarios. If not, consider case studies or simulated environments to practice.

Study Tips for Both Certifications

• Consistency is Key: Make sure to study regularly, breaking down complex topics into manageable chunks.
• Utilize Official Resources: Stick to ISACA-approved materials for both certifications to ensure you cover all necessary content.
• Practice, Practice, Practice: Whether you’re preparing for the CISA or the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate, practice exams are your best tool to gauge readiness and understand the exam format.

Both certifications require diligent preparation, but the CISA certification covers broader content, while the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate focuses more on cybersecurity-specific knowledge. Choosing the right preparation path depends on your current expertise and the certification you’re pursuing.

SEE ALSO: GRC Analyst Roles and Responsibilities

Additional Certifications to Consider

While the CISA certification and the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate are both highly respected and valuable, professionals in IT auditing and cybersecurity may also want to explore additional certifications to broaden their skills and enhance their career opportunities. 

Some certifications complement these credentials by focusing on specific areas of cybersecurity, governance, or auditing.

Complementary Certifications for CISA and Cybersecurity Audit Certificate Holders

As the field of IT security and auditing evolves, professionals may find it beneficial to acquire additional certifications to enhance their expertise. Here are a few options that can complement either the CISA or Cybersecurity Audit Certificate:

1. Certified Information Security Manager (CISM)
   • Also offered by ISACA, the CISM certification is designed for individuals managing, designing, and overseeing an enterprise’s information security program. This certification focuses on the management and governance aspects of information security, making it an excellent complement to CISA or cybersecurity auditing certifications. While CISA is audit-focused, CISM focuses on the leadership and management of information security, helping professionals move into strategic roles.
2. Certified Ethical Hacker (CEH)
   • Offered by the EC-Council, the CEH certification teaches professionals how to think like a hacker and understand the tactics that attackers use to breach systems. For cybersecurity auditors, this knowledge is valuable when assessing vulnerabilities in IT systems. Combining CISA or the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate with CEH can provide a strong foundation for identifying and mitigating security risks.
3. Certified Information Systems Security Professional (CISSP)
   • Often considered one of the most prestigious certifications in the field of information security, the CISSP focuses on the practical application of cybersecurity principles. It covers several domains, including risk management, security architecture, and asset security. CISSP is an excellent complement to both CISA and the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate, as it provides a more technical depth to auditing and governance skills.
4. CompTIA Security+
   • Security+ is a vendor-neutral certification that covers essential cybersecurity concepts, including network security, cryptography, identity management, and risk management. This certification is more entry-level compared to CISA or the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate, but it can provide a solid foundation for those transitioning into the field of cybersecurity.
5. Certified Risk and Information Systems Control (CRISC)
   • Another credential offered by ISACA, CRISC focuses on managing IT risk and ensuring that risk management strategies align with business goals. This certification is particularly valuable for professionals involved in auditing risk management processes, making it an excellent complement to CISA or the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate.

Advantages of Holding Multiple Certifications

Obtaining multiple certifications can significantly enhance your career prospects. Here are some benefits of holding more than one certification:

• Broader Skillset: While CISA focuses on IT systems auditing and the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate specializes in cybersecurity, additional certifications such as CISM or CISSP can provide broader knowledge in information security management and technical cybersecurity skills.
• Increased Marketability: Employers often seek professionals with diverse certifications to ensure they can handle a wide range of tasks, from strategic decision-making to technical problem-solving. Holding multiple certifications makes you more versatile and marketable to potential employers.
• Higher Earning Potential: Combining certifications like CISA and CISSP or CISA and CEH can open doors to higher-paying roles, particularly in leadership positions where both strategic and technical expertise are required.
• Enhanced Job Security: As cybersecurity threats grow more sophisticated, professionals with multiple certifications are more likely to remain relevant in the workforce. Having expertise in several areas makes you indispensable to organizations looking to safeguard their IT systems and data.

Choosing the Right Additional Certification

When deciding on an additional certification, consider your current role, career goals, and the industry you work in. If you aim to move into a more managerial or leadership position, CISM or CRISC might be better options. If you prefer a technical role focused on preventing cyberattacks, CEH or CISSP may be more suitable.

Conclusion

Choosing between the CISA certification and the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate depends on your career aspirations, industry focus, and professional experience. Both certifications are valuable, offering distinct advantages for IT auditors, cybersecurity professionals, and those in risk management roles. 

Understanding the differences between these two certifications is crucial in making an informed decision that aligns with your goals.

The CISA certification provides a broad and comprehensive foundation in IT auditing, governance, and risk management, making it suitable for professionals who seek versatile roles across various industries. It is globally recognized and offers a strong return on investment, especially for those aiming to pursue senior positions in IT governance or risk management.

On the other hand, the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate focuses on auditing within the cybersecurity domain, making it ideal for professionals who want to specialize in the growing field of cybersecurity risk and governance. As cybersecurity threats continue to rise, the demand for specialized knowledge in this area is increasing, making the Cybersecurity Audit Certificate a relevant and timely credential.

Making the Right Choice

Ultimately, the decision between these two certifications comes down to your specific career path:

• CISA is the better choice for those looking for flexibility and a broad understanding of IT auditing and governance.
• Cybersecurity Audit Certificate is perfect for those focused on cybersecurity auditing and risk management in high-risk sectors like finance and healthcare.

Both certifications can enhance your career and offer opportunities for advancement, especially when combined with complementary certifications like CISM, CEH, or CISSP. Consider the costs, preparation time, and future career opportunities when deciding, and remember that each certification can be a stepping stone to higher positions, better salaries, and more specialized roles in IT security and auditing.

FAQ

If you’re ready to take the next step in your cybersecurity journey? You can do that with an expert beside you to guide you through without having to stress much. Schedule a one-on-one consultation with Tolulope Michael, a cybersecurity professional with over a decade of field experience. This will allow you to gain personalized insights and guidance tailored to your career goals.
Visit tolumichael.com now to book your session. This is your opportunity to embark on your cybersecurity career with confidence. Don’t miss out!