Tolulope MichaelCISSP Vs CISM: A Comprehensive Analysis
Among the many certifications available, two of the most respected and sought-after are the Certified Information Systems Security Professional (CISSP) and the Certified Information Security Manager (CISM). Both certifications hold significant value in the industry, but they cater to different career paths and areas of expertise.
Both CISSP vs CISM certifications continue to be highly sought after by organizations aiming to bolster their cybersecurity defenses. The demand for these certifications is expected to grow as cyber threats become increasingly sophisticated.
Specifically, CISSP is favored for its comprehensive coverage of security domains, making it ideal for roles that require both technical and strategic oversight. Meanwhile, CISM’s focus on governance and risk management makes it indispensable for organizations that prioritize regulatory compliance and strategic security management.
The employment of information systems managers, a common role for CISM holders, is projected to grow by 16% by 2031. Additionally, the integration of new technologies and cloud-based services will further enhance the relevance of these certifications, with CISSP holders likely to see opportunities expand in areas like cloud security and cybersecurity architecture. CISM holders will continue to be crucial in strategic roles that align IT security with business objectives
CISSP vs CISM is an important analysis for professionals looking to advance their careers in cybersecurity. This comprehensive comparison will explore the nuances of these certifications, from their focus areas and exam requirements to career opportunities and salary potential.
CISSP Vs CISM: Comparison Table
| Feature | CISSP | CISM | CISA |
| Focus Area | Comprehensive cybersecurity, both technical and managerial | Information security management and governance | IT auditing, control, and compliance |
| Issuing Body | (ISC)² | ISACA | ISACA |
| Key Domains | 8 domains (e.g., Security & Risk Management, Identity & Access Management) | 4 domains (e.g., Information Security Governance, Risk Management) | 5 domains (e.g., Information System Auditing, IT Governance) |
| Ideal Roles | Security Architect, CISO, Security Consultant | Information Security Manager, Risk Manager, CISO | IT Auditor, Compliance Manager, IT Consultant |
| Work Experience Required | 5 years (2 domains) | 5 years (3 years in management roles) | 5 years (Information Systems, IT auditing) |
| Exam Structure | 6 hours, 250 questions | 4 hours, 150 questions | 4 hours, 150 questions |
| Average Salary | $120,000 – $130,000 | $110,000 – $125,000 | $95,000 – $100,000 |
| Cost (Exam + Maintenance) | $749 exam + $125/year | $575 (member) / $760 (non-member) + $45-$85/year | $575 (member) / $760 (non-member) + $45-$85/year |
| Recertification | 120 CPEs over 3 years | 120 CPEs over 3 years | 120 CPEs over 3 years |
| Who Should Choose? | Professionals seeking broad cybersecurity expertise and technical roles | Managers and leaders in information security | IT auditors and professionals in compliance roles |
| Difficulty Level | High (broad technical knowledge required) | Moderate (focus on management and governance) | Moderate (focus on auditing and controls) |
RELATED: OPNsense vs pfSense: A Comparative Analysis
What is CISSP?
The Certified Information Systems Security Professional (CISSP) certification is a globally recognized credential offered by the International Information System Security Certification Consortium, commonly known as (ISC)².
Established in 1989, CISSP has become one of the most prestigious certifications in the field of cybersecurity. It is designed to validate a professional’s expertise in designing, implementing, and managing a best-in-class cybersecurity program.
CISSP covers a broad spectrum of security domains, making it a comprehensive certification that equips professionals with both technical and managerial knowledge.
CISSP is often considered the gold standard for cybersecurity certifications, primarily because of its extensive coverage of security principles across eight domains, including security and risk management, security architecture, and identity and access management.
This certification is ideal for experienced security practitioners, managers, and executives who seek to demonstrate their deep understanding of a wide range of security practices and principles.
What is CISM?
The Certified Information Security Manager (CISM) certification, offered by the Information Systems Audit and Control Association (ISACA), is another highly regarded credential in the cybersecurity industry.
Unlike CISSP, which has a broad focus, CISM is specifically tailored for IT professionals responsible for managing, designing, and overseeing an organization’s information security program.
Established in 2003, CISM emphasizes the management and governance aspects of information security, making it particularly valuable for those looking to advance into leadership roles within their organizations.
CISM certification focuses on four core areas: information security governance, risk management, information security program development and management, and incident management.
This makes CISM an ideal choice for professionals who are more inclined toward the managerial side of cybersecurity, focusing on aligning information security programs with broader business objectives.
Key Differences Between CISSP and CISM: Domains and Focus Areas
One of the most significant differences between CISSP and CISM lies in their respective focus areas and the domains they cover. CISSP is known for its broad and comprehensive approach, encompassing eight distinct domains of cybersecurity:
- Security and Risk Management (15%)
- Asset Security (10%)
- Security Architecture and Engineering (13%)
- Communication and Network Security (13%)
- Identity and Access Management (13%)
- Security Assessment and Testing (12%)
- Security Operations (13%)
- Software Development Security (11%)
These domains ensure that CISSP-certified professionals possess a deep understanding of cybersecurity’s technical and managerial aspects, making them versatile and well-rounded experts in the field.
In contrast, CISM focuses on four core domains, each representing a crucial aspect of managing and governing an organization’s information security:
- Information Security Governance (24%)
- Information Risk Management (30%)
- Information Security Program Development and Management (27%)
- Information Security Incident Management (19%)
CISM’s emphasis is on aligning information security initiatives with business objectives, risk management, and effective incident response. This managerial focus makes CISM particularly appealing to those who aspire to take on leadership roles, such as Chief Information Security Officer (CISO) or Information Security Manager.
Work Experience Requirements
CISSP and CISM certifications are designed for experienced professionals, but the work experience requirements differ slightly.
To qualify for the CISSP certification, candidates must have at least five years of cumulative paid work experience in two or more of the eight domains covered by the CISSP Common Body of Knowledge (CBK). However, candidates can reduce this requirement by one year if they hold a four-year college degree or an approved credential from (ISC)²’s list of accepted certifications.
On the other hand, CISM requires candidates to have a minimum of five years of work experience in information security, with at least three years specifically in information security management roles. Unlike CISSP, CISM allows candidates to waive up to two years of the work experience requirement if they hold certain qualifications or relevant certifications.
Certification Exam Details
The certification exams for CISSP and CISM also differ in structure and content, reflecting their respective focuses.
- CISSP Exam: The CISSP exam is a six-hour-long test consisting of 250 questions. The questions are a mix of multiple-choice and advanced innovative questions, and candidates need to score at least 700 out of 1000 points to pass. The exam is available in various languages and is administered at Pearson VUE testing centers worldwide.
- CISM Exam: The CISM exam is a four-hour test comprising 150 multiple-choice questions. Candidates must score at least 450 on a scale of 200-800 to pass. The exam is also available in multiple languages and can be taken either in person at an authorized testing center or remotely through online proctoring.
When it comes to the difficulty level, a common question arises: “CISSP vs CISM which is harder?” The answer largely depends on the candidate’s background. CISSP is often considered more challenging due to its broader scope and the depth of technical knowledge required across multiple domains.
CISM, while equally rigorous, is more focused on managerial aspects, which may be easier for those with a strong background in information security management.
READ MORE: Google Dork SQL Injection: A Comprehensive Analysis
CISSP vs CISM: Salary Comparison
One of the key factors professionals consider when choosing between CISSP and CISM is the potential impact on their salary. Both certifications are highly respected and can lead to significant salary increases, but they cater to different roles, which can influence earning potential.
On average, CISSP-certified professionals tend to command higher salaries due to the broad and technical nature of the certification. According to recent industry surveys, CISSP holders can expect to earn an average annual salary of around $120,000 to $130,000.
This figure can vary depending on factors such as geographic location, years of experience, and the specific role within an organization.
While enjoying competitive salaries, CISM-certified professionals often find their earnings aligned with management and leadership positions. The average salary for CISM holders typically ranges from $110,000 to $125,000 annually.
While slightly lower than CISSP in some regions, the salary potential for CISM holders is significant, especially in senior management roles where they are responsible for overseeing an organization’s entire information security program.
Career Pathways and Job Roles
The career opportunities associated with CISSP and CISM differ based on the focus of each certification.
CISSP Career Pathways: CISSP is ideal for professionals who aspire to roles requiring a deep understanding of cybersecurity’s technical and managerial aspects. Common job titles for CISSP-certified individuals include:
- Security Architect: Responsible for designing and implementing security systems and infrastructure.
- Chief Information Security Officer (CISO): Oversees the overall security strategy of an organization.
- Security Consultant: Provides expert advice on security practices and solutions.
- Network Security Engineer: Focuses on protecting the integrity and confidentiality of data transmitted across networks.
- Cybersecurity Analyst: Monitors and responds to security incidents and vulnerabilities.
CISSP’s comprehensive coverage of security domains makes it suitable for professionals who want to maintain a balance between technical skills and strategic management.
CISM Career Pathways: CISM is more tailored to professionals who are focused on the governance, risk management, and oversight of information security programs. Typical job roles for CISM-certified professionals include:
- Information Security Manager: Manages developing and implementing security policies and procedures.
- IT Security Consultant: Advises organizations on best practices for managing information security risks.
- Risk Manager: Assesses and mitigates risks to an organization’s information assets.
- Chief Information Security Officer (CISO): Similar to CISSP, but with a stronger emphasis on governance and management rather than technical implementation.
- Governance, Risk, and Compliance (GRC) Lead: Ensures that the organization complies with regulatory requirements and manages security risks effectively.
SEE: Cloud Engineering Vs Cyber Security: A Comprehensive Analysis
CISM vs CISSP Cost: Cost and Recertification Requirements
When considering which certification to pursue, it’s essential to factor in the costs associated with obtaining and maintaining the certification. Both CISSP and CISM have different cost structures, which can influence your decision.
- CISSP Cost: The cost of the CISSP exam is $749, although this can vary slightly depending on your location. In addition to the exam fee, candidates often invest in study materials, training courses, and practice exams, which can add a significant amount to the total cost. After certification, CISSP holders must pay an annual maintenance fee of $125 to keep their certification active. Additionally, they must earn 120 Continuing Professional Education (CPE) credits over three years to maintain their certification.
- CISM Cost: The cost for the CISM exam is $575 for ISACA members and $760 for non-members. Like CISSP, candidates typically incur additional expenses for study materials and training. Once certified, CISM holders must pay an annual maintenance fee of $45 for ISACA members or $85 for non-members. To maintain the CISM certification, professionals must earn 120 CPE credits over a three-year period.
When comparing CISM vs CISSP cost, it’s clear that both certifications require a financial commitment for the initial exam and ongoing maintenance. However, the investment can be worthwhile given the career advancement opportunities that these certifications offer.
Recertification and Continuing Education
Both CISSP and CISM require ongoing education and recertification to ensure that certified professionals remain up-to-date with the latest developments in cybersecurity.
- CISSP Recertification: To maintain the CISSP certification, professionals must earn 120 CPE credits over a three-year cycle. These credits can be earned through various activities, including attending conferences, taking courses, publishing articles, or participating in professional activities related to information security. In addition to earning CPE credits, CISSP holders must pay an annual maintenance fee of $125.
- CISM Recertification: Similar to CISSP, CISM certification requires earning 120 CPE credits over a three-year period. CISM holders can earn these credits through activities such as attending training sessions, conferences, or seminars and contributing to the field through research or teaching. The annual maintenance fee for CISM is lower than CISSP, at $45 for ISACA members and $85 for non-members.
The recertification process for both certifications emphasizes the importance of continuous learning and staying current with industry trends. While the specific costs and requirements may differ, both CISSP and CISM ensure that certified professionals remain knowledgeable and effective in their roles.
READ: Big Data Analytics for Security: A Complete Analysis
CISSP vs CISM vs CISA: How Do They Compare?
What is CISA?
The Certified Information Systems Auditor (CISA) certification is another highly respected credential offered by ISACA.
While CISSP and CISM focus on different aspects of cybersecurity and information security management, CISA is specifically designed for professionals who audit, control, monitor, and assess an organization’s information technology and business systems.
Established in 1978, CISA has become the globally recognized standard for professionals who audit an organization’s IT and business systems.
CISA covers five core domains:
- Information System Auditing Process
- Governance and Management of IT
- Information Systems Acquisition, Development, and Implementation
- Information Systems Operations, Maintenance, and Service Management
- Protection of Information Assets
CISA certification is ideal for IT auditors, audit managers, consultants, and security professionals involved in ensuring the integrity and reliability of an organization’s information systems.
CISSP vs CISM vs CISA
When comparing CISSP, CISM, and CISA, it’s important to recognize that each certification serves a different purpose and caters to distinct professional roles within the cybersecurity and IT governance landscape.
- Focus Areas:
- CISSP: Broadly covers both technical and managerial aspects of cybersecurity, making it suitable for roles that require a comprehensive understanding of security practices and principles.
- CISM: Focuses on information security management, governance, and risk management, making it ideal for professionals aiming for leadership roles in security management.
- CISA: Concentrates on auditing and assessing the effectiveness of an organization’s information systems, making it the go-to certification for IT auditors and professionals involved in compliance and assurance.
- Target Audience:
- CISSP: Aimed at security practitioners, managers, and executives who require expertise across various security domains.
- CISM: Best suited for professionals in or aspiring to management and leadership positions within information security.
- CISA: Tailored for IT auditors, consultants, and professionals responsible for ensuring the integrity and security of information systems.
- Career Pathways:
- CISSP: Roles like Security Architect, Chief Information Security Officer (CISO), Security Consultant, and Network Security Engineer.
- CISM: Positions such as Information Security Manager, IT Security Consultant, Risk Manager, and CISO, with a focus on management.
- CISA: Jobs like IT Auditor, Audit Manager, IT Consultant, and roles focusing on IT governance and compliance.
ALSO READ: IRM vs GRC ServiceNow: A Comprehensive Analysis
CISSP vs CCSP: A Related Certification Comparison
The Certified Cloud Security Professional (CCSP) certification, offered by (ISC)², is a globally recognized credential that focuses on cloud security. As organizations increasingly migrate to cloud environments, the need for specialized security expertise has grown, making CCSP one of the most relevant and in-demand certifications in the cybersecurity industry today.
CCSP is designed to validate a professional’s knowledge and skills in securing cloud environments, covering areas such as cloud architecture, data security, and compliance. It’s particularly suited for IT professionals, security architects, and consultants who are responsible for managing cloud security.
CISSP vs CCSP
While CISSP and CCSP are both offered by (ISC)² and share some common ground, they serve different purposes and cater to distinct aspects of cybersecurity.
- Domains and Focus Areas:
- CISSP: Covers a wide range of cybersecurity domains, including security and risk management, software development security, and identity and access management. It provides a broad foundation in information security’s technical and managerial aspects.
- CCSP: Specifically focuses on cloud security and covers six domains: Cloud Concepts, Architecture, and Design; Cloud Data Security; Cloud Platform and Infrastructure Security; Cloud Application Security; Cloud Security Operations; and Legal, Risk, and Compliance.
- Target Audience:
- CISSP: Aimed at security professionals who need a comprehensive understanding of various security domains, suitable for roles that require both technical expertise and management skills.
- CCSP: Geared towards professionals who specialize in cloud security, including security engineers, cloud architects, and security administrators.
- Career Pathways:
- CISSP: Opens doors to a wide range of roles, from Security Architect to Chief Information Security Officer (CISO), covering both on-premises and cloud environments.
- CCSP: Focuses on cloud-specific roles such as Cloud Security Architect, Cloud Engineer, and Cloud Security Consultant. It’s an excellent choice for professionals who want to specialize in cloud security or enhance their expertise in cloud environments.
- Complementary Certifications:
- Many professionals choose to pursue both CISSP and CCSP to broaden their expertise. CISSP provides a strong foundation in cybersecurity, while CCSP adds specialized knowledge in cloud security, making them complementary certifications that together cover the full spectrum of information security in modern IT environments.
ALSO SEE: AI Vs Cybersecurity: A Comprehensive Analysis
Which Certification is Right for You?
Choosing between CISSP and CISM ultimately depends on your career aspirations and the specific skills you wish to develop. If your goal is to gain a comprehensive understanding of cybersecurity, including both technical and managerial aspects, CISSP is the better choice.
CISSP’s broad coverage of eight domains makes it suitable for professionals who want to maintain versatility in their roles, whether as a Security Architect, Chief Information Security Officer (CISO), or Security Consultant.
On the other hand, if you are more inclined towards the governance, risk management, and leadership aspects of information security, CISM may be more aligned with your career goals.
CISM is ideal for those aiming for roles such as Information Security Manager, Risk Manager, or IT Security Consultant, where the focus is on managing and aligning security programs with business objectives.
Industry Trends and Future-Proofing Your Career
Cybersecurity is constantly developing, with new threats and technologies emerging regularly. Both CISSP and CISM are highly respected certifications that can significantly enhance your career prospects, but staying informed about industry trends is crucial for long-term success.
- CISSP: With its broad coverage and focus on both technical and managerial skills, CISSP is a versatile certification that prepares professionals for a wide range of roles. As cybersecurity threats continue to evolve, the demand for professionals with a CISSP certification remains strong, particularly in roles that require a deep understanding of complex security architectures and systems.
- CISM: The emphasis on governance and risk management makes CISM particularly valuable in organizations that prioritize regulatory compliance and effective security management. As businesses increasingly recognize the importance of aligning their security strategies with overall business objectives, the demand for CISM-certified professionals is expected to grow.
In some cases, pursuing both certifications might be the best strategy for future-proofing your career. For example, a CISSP can provide you with the technical knowledge to address complex security challenges, while a CISM can equip you with the managerial skills to lead and implement effective security programs.
Additionally, certifications like CCSP can further enhance your expertise in specific areas, such as cloud security, making you even more versatile and competitive in the job market.
MORE: Endpoint Security Checklist: A Comprehensive Analysis
Conclusion
Certifications like CISSP and CISM play a critical role in career advancement. Both certifications offer distinct benefits and cater to different professional paths.
CISSP is ideal for those seeking a broad understanding of cybersecurity, including both technical and managerial aspects. At the same time, CISM is more suited for professionals focused on the governance, risk management, and leadership side of information security.
Understanding the differences between CISSP and CISM and how they compare to other certifications like CISA and CCSP is crucial for making an informed decision that aligns with your career goals.
Whether you choose CISSP, CISM, or a combination of certifications, investing in your professional development through these credentials will significantly enhance your marketability and career opportunities in cybersecurity.
FAQ
Which one is better, CISM or CISSP?
The choice between CISM and CISSP depends on your career goals and interests. CISM is better suited for professionals who want to focus on information security management and governance aspects.
It’s ideal for those aspiring to roles like Information Security Manager, Risk Manager, or Chief Information Security Officer (CISO) with a strong emphasis on aligning security strategies with business objectives.
On the other hand, CISSP is more appropriate for those who seek a comprehensive understanding of cybersecurity, covering both technical and managerial aspects. CISSP is ideal for roles like Security Architect, Security Consultant, and CISO, especially if you want to maintain versatility across various domains of cybersecurity.
Ultimately, neither certification is objectively “better” than the other; it depends on the specific skills and career path you wish to pursue.
Which is better, CISA or CISSP?
CISSP is generally considered better for professionals who want a broad and deep understanding of cybersecurity, including both technical and managerial aspects. It’s well-suited for roles that require comprehensive knowledge across multiple security domains, such as Security Architect, CISO, or Security Consultant.
CISA, on the other hand, is better for those focused on auditing, controlling, and assessing information systems. It’s ideal for IT auditors, compliance professionals, and consultants who specialize in evaluating the effectiveness of an organization’s IT systems and ensuring they meet regulatory requirements.
Choosing between CISA and CISSP depends on whether you prefer to work on the technical and strategic aspects of cybersecurity (CISSP) or on the auditing and assurance side of IT systems (CISA).
How much do CISSP holders make compared to CISM?
On average, CISSP holders tend to earn slightly more than CISM holders due to the broader technical scope and the high demand for CISSP-certified professionals in various security roles. The average salary for a CISSP-certified professional is typically in the range of $120,000 to $130,000 per year.
CISM holders generally earn between $110,000 and $125,000 annually. The salary differences can vary depending on factors such as location, experience, and the specific role within the organization.
While CISSP might offer higher earning potential overall, CISM-certified professionals also enjoy competitive salaries, particularly in senior management and leadership roles.
Which is better, CISM or CISA?
CISM is better suited for professionals who aim to manage and govern an organization’s information security program. It’s ideal for those looking to advance into roles like Information Security Manager or CISO, where the focus is on risk management, governance, and aligning security strategies with business objectives.
CISA, however, is better for those who specialize in IT auditing, control, and assessment. It’s perfect for IT auditors, compliance professionals, and consultants who ensure that an organization’s IT systems are secure and compliant with regulations.
The choice between CISM and CISA depends on whether your career goals align more with managing information security programs (CISM) or auditing and evaluating IT systems (CISA).
If you’re ready to take the next step in your cybersecurity journey? You can do that with an expert beside you to guide you through without having to stress much. Schedule a one-on-one consultation with Tolulope Michael, a cybersecurity professional with over a decade of field experience. This will allow you to gain personalized insights and guidance tailored to your career goals.
Visit tolumichael.com now to book your session. This is your opportunity to embark on your cybersecurity career with confidence. Don’t miss out!
